My Thoughts on the Salvadoran Election

March 17, 2009

I came down to El Salvador last week to visit friends and be here for an historic presidential election. As I’m sure you may have heard (or maybe not considering how Central American doesn’t exactly dominate US news cycles), on Sunday, for the first time since gaining independence from Spain a century and a half ago, Salvadorans elected a leftist president. The first Salvadoran president not from the ruling elite or a military caudillo.

In Mauricio Funes, the FMLN, which is made up of ex-guerillas and became an official party after the 1992 peace accords, nominated a non ex-combatant for the first time. In a country where most major media outlets are parrots for the government, Funes was a popular television journalist with a reputation for asking hard questions and speaking truth to power. For lack of a better comparison, he is El Salvador’s Tim Russert.

Funes was an impressive candidate in many ways. He campaigned as a moderate, talked about the importance of a good relationship with the United States, and traded in his red FMLN gear for white guayaberas, dark business suits and designer glasses. His campaign even gain the backing of Salvadoran businessman. In television interviews, he skillfully answered loaded questions. When the right tried to paint him as a radical who would become a Salvadoran Chavez, he kept his cool. His campaign billboards, television spots, and posters had a level of message sophistication atypical of FMLN campaigns. That message was inspirational, with themes similar to Barack Obama’s — hope, change, depolarization of politics.

Beyond Funes himself, the election says a lot about how far El Salvador has come as a people. The country and its politics are still very polarized, seventeen years after the end of a 12-year long civil war that spilled the blood of 75,000 people, including American nuns, Spanish Jesuits, scores of Salvadoran priests and Archbishop Oscar Romero (whom many regard as a modern-day saint). I would be remiss to not mention that the Reagan Administration fueled the civil war to the tune of $1.5 million a day despite reports of atrocoties committed by the Salvadoran government. (This election, Obama’s State Dept. publicly stated neutrality on the race, a big shift from the Bush Administration, who in 2004 said an FMLN win would harm El Salvador’s relationship with the US. Several members of Congress penned a letter to Sec. Clinton asking that TPS [temporary protective status] be revisited for Salvadoran immigrants if the FMLN were to win).

Yet despite this violent recent history, a peaceful transfer of power is about to take place.

The right tried to scare people into voting for ARENA, labeling the FMLN as violent communists, a misleading characterization that didn’t even fit them during the war. But it didn’t work this time. The newspapers looked like advertisements for ARENA and slammed the FMLN. But Funes’s message still got out, in large part thanks to the democratizing force of the internet (Half of El Salvador’s population is under 25 and grows more internet savvy by the day). That overwhelmingly young population, born after the war or not old enough to remember it, isn’t falling for Cold War rhetoric. And even some veterans of the civil war who fought on the side of the government, joined up with their former combat adversaries to back Funes.

When the election results were announced, word spread that people would gather to celebrate at Redondel Masferrer, a large traffic circle in an upscale neighborhood, essentially in ARENA’s back yard, named after another famous Salvadoran journalist. Tens of thousands of FMLN supporters came. They cut through the Citi Bank parking lot, crowded onto the balconies of a modern shopping center, and filed in and out of the Burger King to see television coverage of ARENA party candidate Rodrigo Avila’s concession speech.

See photos from Masferrer and Election Day here.

Those gathered were not just political activists celebrating their candidate’s victory. Some were campesinos who spent years in refugee camps during the war before being able to travel back to their hometowns… torture victims persecuted for their political beliefs or for being related to or knowing someone who held political beliefs deemed subversive… survivors of massacres… ex-combatants who lived the horrors of war and have never received treatment for the psychological trauma they endured… US residents and citizens who fled El Salvador for political or economic reasons years ago and came back to vote and witness this historic event… children belonging to all of the above who have learned from their elders that the 80s is not a road they want to go down again.

And many more were mothers and fathers, brothers and sisters, who until this day, have constantly wondered: Did my loved one die in vain?

That’s a tremendous burden to place on one person. Despite the high hopes and expectations, like President Obama, Funes faces seemingly insurmountable problems.

As many as 60% of Salvadorans live in poverty and probably another 20% live on the brink. As much as one third of El Salvador’s GDP comes from remittances sent home from the millions of Salvadoran relatives who live and work in the US. In short, El Salvador’s number one export is people, which adds a multiplying effect to the current economic crisis. The country desperately needs an alternative approach to the rampant gang problem — to not just lock up young people in overcrowded prisons where they fester with fellow gang members, but to give the country’s youth an alternative to violence. But before tackling these and other problems, Funes will have to assemble a team from a pool of people who have never governed before. And the press and the political right aren’t likely going to give him much time before declaring him a failure.

That’s what lies ahead, but for now, El Salvador and this foreign observer are relishing in the symbolism of the moment — the power of the human spirit to walk through hell and still maintain a flicker of hope that it will emerge… the capacity for understanding and reconciliation of the once bitterly divided… how, with time, democracy can exist in a land with such a long and enduring history of repression.

Funes and Supporters Celebrate Victory in San Salvador

March 16, 2009

I’ve uploaded the photos from the victory celebration for FMLN candidate and president-elect Mauricio Funes. Tens of thousands of supporters gathered at Redondel Masferrer, a traffic circle in an upscale neighborhood in San Salvador once a Funes victory appeared inevitable. The atmosphere was euphoric, as last night’s decision marks the first time a candidate from El Salvador’s left-wing party has won the presidency.

FMLN candidate Mauricio Funes addresses a crowd of supporters at Redondel Masferrer in San Salvador after declaring victory in El Salvador's presidential election, Sunday, March 15, 2009

FMLN candidate Mauricio Funes greets supporters at Redondel Masferrer in San Salvador after declaring victory in El Salvador's presidential election, Sunday, March 15, 2009

See more photos here:

Funes Victory

March 16, 2009

FMLN candidate Mauricio Funes has won a historic victory in El Salvador’s presidential election. Funes will be the first leftist president in a country that remains sharply divided nearly twenty years after the end of a 12-year long civil war in which 75,000 people were killed.

I took a lot of pictures tonight and there are plenty of good articles about the election out there, but I will have to post an update tomorrow. It’s been a long day with a lot of walking in the hot sun, and I need some rest.

Election Day Photos

March 16, 2009
A Salvadoran woman searches the voting rolls for her assigned polling booth at a poll in Ciudad Delgado, San Salvador.

A Salvadoran woman searches the voting rolls for her assigned polling booth at a poll in Ciudad Delgado, San Salvador.

I went around town and took some photos today. I had some trouble uploading them, so I have not added captions yet, though most are pretty self-explanatory. The ones taken at night are from my neighborhood in Washington, Mount Pleasant, which has a large Salvadoran population. You can follow election results at www.elfaro.net. There’s a banner across the top with the current percentages.

See more photos here.

‘Yes, we can!’ slogan did not originate with Barack Obama’s campaign

March 15, 2009

I’m getting a little tired of American news outlets’ ignorance to the fact that the phrase “Yes, we can!” adopted by the Obama campaign has long been used in Latin America and by Hispanics in the US in it’s Spanish version: Si, se puede.

The Washington Times editorial board should know better. So should William Booth of the Washington Post. Do these guys have fact checkers?

As far as I can tell, it was first used by Cesar Chavez and Dolores Huerta in the United Farmworkers campaign in 1972. Ever since, it’s often been the campaign slogan of Latin American leaders from across the political spectrum. I remember Nicaraguans joking about posters used in Enrique Bolanos’s campaign for that country’s presidency, where it was unclear if there was an accent or a dot over the “i.” With an accent “Si” means “yes.” Without, it means “if.” There’s a very big difference between “If we can” and “Yes, we can.”

Cabbie Wisdom

March 15, 2009

Tonight, after meeting up with a friend who is here to observe at his hotel, I took a cab back to the friend’s house where I am staying. Cabbies are often great sources of wisdom, but this particular one had a metaphor I thought was worth sharing.

The streets of San Salvador are empty tonight because of the Ley Seca, which prohibits the sale of alcohol from 12:00 am on Saturday through Election Day. I commented on the deserted streets and he said that everyone was in their houses, a third of whom are simply anxious about the outcome of the race, another third who cannot wait to find out the results, and the final third who are absolutely desperate to know the outcome, and one in 1000 who are actually able to enjoy the moment they’re currently living in. But, he said, no matter what we’ll know the results by this time tomorrow.

He asked if my preferred candidate was the same as his preferred candidate, Mauricio Funes. I replied that as a foreigner I did not have a preference. He persisted. I conceded that the Funes campaign has been impressive and inspired the country, much in the way Obama’s campaign inspired Americans.

He replied with this excellent metaphor: Say I invite a woman to go with me in my car to the beach to eat some fish at a nice restaurant. She says yes, not knowing that I only have enough money to pay for the gas to put in my car. But once I get her there it doesn’t matter that I can’t afford the fish, she already went with me to the beach.

That was probably worth not being able to haggle him down from five to four dollars.

Caught On Tape — Arena Party Activists Initiate Altercation with FMLN Supporters

March 15, 2009

On Tuesday afternoon, ARENA party activists held a rally outside of Metro Centro (one of San Salvador’s main shopping malls). A large trolley-like vehicle decorated with ARENA flags was parked in the median in front of the mall and supporters in ARENA t-shirts waved flags at the intersection. I happened to see this while traveling by bus to meet up with a friend.

The next morning, an altercation between these ARENA supporters and the FMLN was front page news, which included a photo of the damaged ARENA vehicle. The reporting suggested FMLN supporters initiated an attack. There have been many claims by the ARENA party of acts of violence by FMLN supporters, and the alleged acts have received extensive coverage. Portraying the FMLN as violent is a key component of the ARENA party’s message. Such messaging no doubt conjurs up memories of El Salvador’s violent past.

But the video below which aired on Channel 21 proves that this particular incident was provoked by ARENA supporters participating in the rally. A video camera caught ARENA members getting out of a vehicle in front of the trolley, taking rocks out of backpacks and throwing them at FMLN supporters on the other side of the street.

Univision interviews with Avila and Funes

March 14, 2009

Both candidates were interviewed by the Univision public affairs program Al Punto. Sorry, this is in Spanish. Lots of loaded questions from the host for both of them. Avila has probably never faced such tough questions. At one point, the host challenges Funes’s journalistic integrity for not answering directly if he thought Chavez and Castro were dictators. But the former television journalist chides the gotcha nature of the question and his questioner, saying as a host he would never ask such a question.

ARENA party candidate and former police chief Rodrigo Avila appears pretty nervous throughout the interview. The most interesting moment comes when he is asked if he has ever killed anyone. Avila dodges the question and even says outright: I won’t answer that question directly. When pressed, he says he has defended himself when necessary, just as he will defend Salvadorans as president. Then he is pressed again with a quote from a previous interview where he answered the same question in the affirmative. Wow!

Funes interview:

Avila interview:

Election coverage round-up

March 14, 2009

There are at least a couple of thousand international journalists in El Salvador covering this historic presidential election, which has resulted in extensive English-language coverage. They are filled with colorful anecdotes that highlight the country’s polarized politics and economy, while revealing how Mauricio Funes, the first moderate and non ex-combatant candidate put forth by the FMLN, has the potential to reduce some of that polarity.

  • For those new to Salvadoran politics and need some historical context, this LA Times editorial offers context and calls for less negative campaigning.
  • My friend Kelly Creedon has a great piece in the Christian Science Monitor on the political shift among some of El Salvador’s Christian evangelicals. Be sure to watch the photo slideshow.
  • LA Times on a former  Salvadoran military commander who is campaigning for Funes alongside a former FMLN guerilla commander. They are visiting long-time FMLN strongholds — places where soldiers under his command fought and even killed members of those towns.
  • AP on the influence Salvadorans living in the United States have on the election. Includes population and remittances data.
  • The Chicago Tribune on the influence of Chavez and the US.
  • AFP on the US State Dept’s neutrality on the election. In the past, high level US govt officials have implied that electing the FMLN would put the TPS (temporary protective status) in jeopardy for Salvadorans living in the US.

Bringing the blog back to life

March 14, 2009

Ok, so I have been pretty busy in the last year with the U.S. presidential election, and have failed to produce any more blogposts. But now I am in El Salvador, on the day before the country’s historic presidential election, and the 140-character limit on Twitter is no longer sufficient. So welcome to Alli No Mas, a blog I created last year with the intention of regularly posting on Latin American travel, politics and culture. Maybe you can come back again for travel tips before your next trip to Central America. And maybe this trip will inspire me to revive my blog.

You can also follow me on Twitter @ortmanc, or if we are Facebook friends, through my feed which is temporarily connected to my Twitter account.

Chris


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.